How late are timesheets approved for the quarter-start review: research question and scope
This review asks how long a timesheet waits between the end of the pay period and the approval that releases it to payroll. The scope covers the first two pay periods of the quarter, when new schedules and authorizations are most likely to create mismatches. It includes timesheets that were approved on time, approved late, and still open at the payroll cutoff. It excludes pay adjustments that were handled as a separate correction after the payroll file was submitted, unless the same hours also appear in the original timesheet.
The start event is the close of the pay period, not the date the caregiver submitted the sheet. The stop event is the approval that makes the hours payable, not the date the sheet was opened. If a timesheet is returned for correction, keep the original start event and record the return and resubmission. That rule lets the review measure the total delay rather than only the final review step.
Population and unit of analysis
The population is every timesheet for a caregiver who was scheduled during the pay period. The unit is one caregiver-pay-period timesheet, even when it contains several visits. If a timesheet is split by payer or territory, treat each split as a separate unit and link them to the same caregiver. That link is useful when one part is approved and another is held.
Stratify by visit type, payer, and whether the timesheet included a corrected visit. A timesheet with a correction is more likely to wait for a second review. The timesheet approval routine describes the daily control that the review is testing. Use its definition of approval so the sample is consistent across reviewers.
Definitions and measures
A timesheet is on time when the approval date is on or before the internal deadline. It is late when the approval date is after the deadline but before the payroll file is locked. It is at risk when it is still open at the payroll cutoff. Keep those categories separate, because a late approval that still makes payroll is a different problem from an approval that misses payroll.
The primary measure is the median delay from pay-period close to approval. Secondary measures include the share approved after the internal deadline, the share still open at the cutoff, and the number of timesheets returned for a missing visit record. Report the denominator and the exact window. A delay measured in days is easier to compare than a percentage without a time frame.
Evidence standard
The evidence is the timesheet record, the approval timestamp, and the visit log used to support the hours. A status field that says "approved" without an approver and a timestamp is weak. If the approval happened in a message thread, the record should link to that message or summarize it with a date and a name. The reviewer should be able to see what was approved, not just that someone clicked a button.
The evidence should also show whether the visit log was complete at the time of approval. A timesheet approved with a missing visit is not the same as one approved after the record was matched. The timesheet latency study explains why this distinction matters. Use the same evidence rule for every stratum so the comparison is fair.
Sampling and collection
Sample from the payroll calendar, not from a list of timesheets that were flagged. Start with every timesheet in the pay period, then select a stratified sample that includes on-time, late, and at-risk cases. Capture the pay-period close, the submission date, the approval date, the approver, and any return or correction. Record the visit log status at the time of approval.
Include the first pay period of the quarter and the second, because the first may be affected by new schedules while the second may show whether the process settled. Record the collection date and the source system. If the payroll system overwrites the approval history, export the data before the next period closes. A later reconstruction from memory is not evidence.
Analysis and reporting
Report the median delay, the range, and the share approved after the internal deadline. Then show the most common reason for a return and one dated example. If the delay is concentrated in timesheets with a missing visit, the problem may be the visit capture process. If the delay is spread across all timesheets, the problem may be reviewer capacity or an unrealistic deadline.
Break the results down by approver role and by payer. A payer-specific delay may reflect an authorization issue rather than a payroll issue. Do not rank individual approvers by name; the sample is too small and the case mix may explain the difference. The agency cover review is a useful cross-check when a late timesheet also involves an agency shift.
Limits and sources of error
The review measures the approval process, not the accuracy of every hour paid. A fast approval can still contain an error, and a late approval can be correct. The review should not be presented as proof that payroll was accurate. It shows whether the evidence was reviewed before the deadline, which is a separate control.
Other limits include approvals recorded outside the payroll system, timesheets that were corrected after the payroll file was locked, and pay periods with a holiday or a system outage. Note those events in the report because they can explain an outlier. If the sample is small, report counts alongside percentages. A single late timesheet can look dramatic as a percentage and modest as a count.
Review cadence
Review approval delay every pay period during the quarter, with a deeper analysis at the quarter start. The pay-period check can use a small sample and focus on the internal deadline. The quarter-start review should repeat the same definitions and include the prior quarter's result for comparison. If the deadline changes, label the new rule and keep the old result.
Assign the review to a named role and set a follow-up date for any recommended change. The follow-up should confirm whether the deadline, the visit capture step, or the approver backup actually changed. A report without a follow-up is only a description of the past. The goal is a payroll process that pays accurately and on time, with evidence that a reviewer can follow.
